Hey Beno, Ive been waiting for this question
If the longer bump stops are no longer available ( They are a pain to fit, not impossible though), Its simple, go the hydro type.
The last ones in your pics. So easy to fit, easy to replace, and just like the original bump stops, will prevent your suspension from over traveling.
After all, thats their primary function, to stop over travel.
There are some front sub frame mods that can be made to strengthen them, but if you keep good rubber donuts, maintain good height via adjustable cones, and dont travel many ks on dirt or corrugated surfaces, I doubt the subframe will cop too much.
I agree with Yellaterra, it's a last protection .
Its unlikely the bump stop will even come into play if your donuts and shockies are in good condition
Thanks Yellaterra,
That helps put things into perspective. What would the difference be if I swapped.
As in, if instead of having the shorter replacements go in the same spot as the originals what would happen if I switch and put the other type on the upper control arm instead of attaching direct to the subframe?
On some models where the shorter bump stops were fitted, the factory welded some plates onto the control arms. Over travel is our enemy here Beno. You can try and find the original long bump stop rubbers, or fit the shorter bump stops along with the control arms with the plate welded on them, or fit the hydro bump stops.
All will give you the protection from over travel. Its up to you how much effort you want to give to achieve the same result.
Any questions happily answered or discussed, its a very good topic youve chosen to talk about
Halfpint